Half in the Bag: Joker


Comments • 7 912

  • Dapstart
    Dapstart  6 minutes back

    "I was unexpectedly surprised"

    Mike's a goddamn lyrical genius

    • Steve Waelde
      Steve Waelde  20 minutes back

      Jay, I think the idea of an upset mass of people in Gotham was hinted at a few times in the beginning (Garbage union protests, mass dissent against the mayor etc). The Killing on the subway was the incident that inspired the movement to take on a clown identity even though the movement had seemingly already existed.

      • political dissonance
        political dissonance  37 minutes back

        Fucking dumb review. I dont like the director, it make film bad. Me not forget. Fuck you

        • julk cabrera
          julk cabrera  37 minutes back

          Fucking snobs

          • Mark Boccella
            Mark Boccella  46 minutes back

            People say that his laughter at the comedy club was completely random but i saw it as his lack of timing. He seemed to be hyper focused and somewhat in tune with the punch lines just slower than a healthy minded person.

            • Thor Agust
              Thor Agust  46 minutes back

              why would they establish the story line any more as far as joker knows about it because we are seeing the story unfold from his perspective and the joker doesn't fully understand why there are riots so neither should we

              • Ben Quinney
                Ben Quinney  1 hours back

                No personal checks?!?!

                • Ben Quinney
                  Ben Quinney  1 hours back

                  Shots fired

                  • TheOwlCreek
                    TheOwlCreek  1 hours back

                    Jay, I can't and won't make this any simpler for you. You failed at life. You failed. When one thinks of what man is capable of, pushing himself to the limits physically, mentally and emotionally to achieve heights of success never before mentioned, your name will not be whispered in the same, reverent fashion that others have. Nobody will remember Jay Bauman. You aren't even a header or a footer in the career of someone else. You are nobody. Nothing. Nada. Zilch. In short, you are an enormous failure. Jay, being that you're about 30 years old and your brain has probably hard-wired itself to accept such failures by now and write off such criticism by being "flippant", really suggests that you've passed beyond the proverbial breaking-point. There's no turning back. This is your career, this is what defines you and this is what you'll defend to the end. The abhorrent failure that is Red Letter Media, Jay Bauman, that is your legacy. Maybe I'm over-reaching, however. Who knows? People CAN change. Maybe you'll read this, Jay, and think long and hard about what a wasteful life you've led. Maybe you'll think, "wow. It's incredible just how abysmal and pathetic I really AM!" Maybe you'll lift some weights in the morning. Maybe you'll take a self-help class. Maybe in a couple of years, Jay, you'll have learned from this failure. I doubt it, though. I genuinely doubt it.

                    • B C
                      B C  2 hours back

                      after this movie I wanna shoot my moms gun in school

                      • D Hicks
                        D Hicks  4 hours back

                        It’s strange. I don’t watch movies anymore, I watch Red Letter Media reviews of movies.

                        • Triplicity Uk
                          Triplicity Uk  5 hours back

                          Really nicely edited episode! Watching Mike looking at Jay missing the point was tense!

                          • JATTITN
                            JATTITN  5 hours back

                            Seems like Jay didn't actually watch the movie and based all of his criticism off of cliff notes or something. I've never seen him miss out on so many key points. re-watch the movie fellas.

                            • Eye Patch Guy
                              Eye Patch Guy  4 hours back

                              It’s pointless. I can tell that Jay wanted to dislike this movie from the get go. He saw the hype, it didn’t resonate with him, and he had to rationalise any disdain.

                          • Grail
                            Grail  5 hours back

                            Is it fair to think that Arthur already had the Joker personality. Society supressed it with drugs and healthcare / therepy, with his alter ego always present behind the scenes, uncontrollably reminding us it's there through his condition. The moment the drugs and help stop it starts becoming more prominent. The last scene of him laughing at Wayne's murder finally is unleashed. Gotham made him. (Maybe. Anyhoo, this film has many layers, hope they don't make a sequel because they will have to settle for one.)

                            • Kazushi Saku57
                              Kazushi Saku57  5 hours back

                              The Joker reminded of a person who has the Fallout (videogame) "Idiot Savant" perk.

                              • Cymen
                                Cymen  5 hours back

                                Jay: We didn't need all those flashbacks!

                                Also Jay: They never established he stopped taking his pills, that the city was at the brink of chaos, there was no transformation at all, he was always crazy!

                                • Stranger
                                  Stranger  5 hours back

                                  I expect better from you guys, the criticisms here are pretty darn weak.

                                  • Harry Haller
                                    Harry Haller  6 hours back

                                    Jay is such a tool. God. Hope you read this Jay.

                                    • Cassidy Rich
                                      Cassidy Rich  6 hours back

                                      I think you had decided to not like it before you went into the movie

                                    • Obo299
                                      Obo299  6 hours back

                                      What the hell was that Phoenix clip at the end?

                                      • Hugo
                                        Hugo  7 hours back

                                        You did NOT see the girlfriend twist coming, Jay, get the fuck outta here.

                                        • Pasi Kähönen
                                          Pasi Kähönen  7 hours back

                                          I was hoping that when he climbed inside the fridge, that as a twist, he would actually become Mr. Freeze... but no 😑

                                          • Zuya Isna
                                            Zuya Isna  7 hours back

                                            top comments are about Jay being an idiot LOL I paused and stopped watching at the moment I heard his rant, and look what has happened.

                                            • Gage Dubois
                                              Gage Dubois  7 hours back

                                              RLM. Sometimes very funny, but a lot of the time they become the people they mock, hurling oit insults or blatant lies. Loud = funny.

                                              Honestly i think they think they're waaaay bigger than they are. Huge egos, acting so smug or like they're above other youtube channels despite their sub count growing at a crawling pace. And dont even get me started on the overrated Plinkett reviews.
                                              Honestly i just mostly hate Jay.

                                              Mike and Rich are still so funny. And i still enjoy many videos like best of the worst.

                                              • MisterAlerion
                                                MisterAlerion  7 hours back

                                                Jay didn't watch the fucking movie

                                                • J Gonz
                                                  J Gonz  8 hours back

                                                  This comment section gives me life. Thank you all for checking Jay and Mike's critiques.

                                                  • Earl of Doncaster
                                                    Earl of Doncaster  8 hours back

                                                    "Age of Reactions." Reactionary does not mean a propensity to react. Reactionary is nostalgia for a golden age in the past, real or imagined.

                                                    • Adastra14
                                                      Adastra14  8 hours back

                                                      Jay, come on man... still subbed though. <3

                                                      • Derek Connors
                                                        Derek Connors  8 hours back

                                                        Guys, the Plinkett Reviews are the ones where they do in depth research and carefully plot out their arguments. Half in the Bag in just their initial reaction after one viewing. They miss shit all the time in these reviews. So don't act so offended because Jay missed a few details.

                                                        He wasn't even totally negative, he just said it was a little sloppy. He's not wrong.

                                                        • Adventurestud
                                                          Adventurestud  8 hours back

                                                          Ha ha ha! How soon before these two clowns change their tunes?

                                                          • inkbl0ts
                                                            inkbl0ts  9 hours back

                                                            Single mother in Gotham slums leaves door unlocked.

                                                            • Giantdad Lives
                                                              Giantdad Lives  13 hours back

                                                              This film has a lot of themes, some of which you guys touched upon like mental illness and classism, but I think you missed out the biggest which is the warning of victimhood and of the dangers of victimising someone with nothing to lose and then acting like you had nothing to do with it. It's the pathology of (edgy maymay incoming) the society we live in, not too dissimilar to this 'incel' thing that's been going around lately: we pathologise 'slut shaming' and then in the same breath make fun of lonely, sad, angry people for not having sex? In the same vein, DeNiro, a wealthy and powerful social actor, attempts to denigrate Arthur, a destitute, mentally ill man, even further for entertainment value but then claim a moral high-ground when Arthur reveals he killed in retaliation?

                                                              Leftists hated the film before it even came out because they thought it was a celebration of a white male taking his gun out and killing everyone he didn't like, which they ascribe to some amorphous 'incel' fantasy failing to see that Arthur isn't a hero or a villain, but a victim, and a person that believes they are a victim is someone who will find any justification to do something awful to amend it. You can only marginalise people for so long before they become so numerous that they refuse to be as such, and this film is a warning to people to make an effort to reintegrate them instead of denigrating them, or we'll all be eaten alive.

                                                              • Henry Walsh
                                                                Henry Walsh  13 hours back

                                                                Guys maybe the movie isn't as smart as you think it is

                                                                • Papa J
                                                                  Papa J  13 hours back

                                                                  Did you miss the start of the film? It goes through all the build up of social issues.

                                                                  • Vladan Markovic
                                                                    Vladan Markovic  14 hours back

                                                                    I think a Joker deserves re:View episode. Would like to see Mike and Jay go deeper on this one.

                                                                    • Nick
                                                                      Nick  15 hours back

                                                                      "fuck movies"

                                                                      • spatrickf
                                                                        spatrickf  15 hours back

                                                                        I think the hardest part about the film, for me, was how that guy, with his obvious damage & developmental disabilities, becomes the criminal mastermind we all know him to be.

                                                                        • Neil Lolmaugh
                                                                          Neil Lolmaugh  16 hours back

                                                                          I said the same thing Mike said. This would be a fantastic soft reboot of the DCU. Make this Joker the basis for the eventual Batman Joker.

                                                                          • Devin Carter
                                                                            Devin Carter  16 hours back

                                                                            Got to love how when HITB doesn't agree with your sheep and hero worship opinions, suddenly folks " went in not wanting to like the movie" or "insights were off". This movie was an overrated piece of trash that Joaquin saved with weird acting.

                                                                            No way this Joker can ever become TDK Joker and it was just a cash grab by the loser classes who with overidentify.

                                                                            • WhyIt
                                                                              WhyIt  16 hours back

                                                                              Well, the revolution really started when Thomas Wayne started saying that the citizens are clowns like the day after the killing. It didn't start simply because upper class people died, but because the underprivileged lower class 99% were practically being mocked and shamed for shit they weren't responsible for. That was the tipping point for lower class being convinced that the upper class and political figures didn't have their best interests at heart.

                                                                              I'm pretty sure they literally show him going off his meds in multiple scenes before he straight out says "I went off my meds". Like, it started with the scene where the government funding was dropped and there's a part where it shows that he ran out of his last supply.

                                                                              Jay, what the fuck were you doing while watching this movie? Were you staring at a photo Todd Philips on your phone when all the important shit was happening?

                                                                              • Joshua Bass
                                                                                Joshua Bass  18 hours back

                                                                                Joker will do for psychopath origin stories what Jaws did for the ocean

                                                                                • DarkenedProgress
                                                                                  DarkenedProgress  18 hours back

                                                                                  I can agree with both opinions. While I liked all the things that Mike enjoyed and then some, I also felt like the movie was more than a bit sloppy throughout. Even though I enjoyed the relatively slow burn of the film, the pacing was clearly off at times or during certain scenes. Additionally, while Phoenix's portrayal of the character was over all quite masterful, there were more than a few stilted or awkward lines and shots from the supporting cast that made the world less believable.

                                                                                  • NephAF
                                                                                    NephAF  19 hours back

                                                                                    How did you guys not talk about the painful Batman tie in where they literally show the same death scene that has been showed 10 times already. That was my biggest complaint with the film, aside from that I really enjoyed it. They shoulda just left that out, or implied it rather than shown it.

                                                                                    • Undead Slayer
                                                                                      Undead Slayer  19 hours back

                                                                                      and the parts in his head they felt real

                                                                                      • Undead Slayer
                                                                                        Undead Slayer  19 hours back

                                                                                        the theater i went had great audio the gun was loud when he shot the 3 guys scared me also ive seen nearly all movies this year in theater havent had as much fun as i did with joker loved the music and the setting of it reminds me of the early 80s

                                                                                        • Angry Badger
                                                                                          Angry Badger  19 hours back

                                                                                          Joker in Batman '89 wasn't just a random thug, he was a top-tier gangster who pretty much ran the seedy underbelly of Gotham..

                                                                                          • Luis Conrado Parra
                                                                                            Luis Conrado Parra  20 hours back

                                                                                            just hope this doesn't inspire Rich Evans to do anything cuckoo

                                                                                            • Cambodia Joe
                                                                                              Cambodia Joe  20 hours back

                                                                                              Joker's killing the rich guys was the spark of the protests that have been building a long time.
                                                                                              Arab spring across several countries that took down multiple governments was sparked by one Tunisian street food seller guy .
                                                                                              That is how it works. I thought that the society decay was pretty clear, if nothing else in the example of Arthur.