My Friend And I Liked The Same Guy

  • Published: 16 July 2019
  • By Nikki | Subscribe: | Comment, like, share this story.
    Stand up against people who judge others and use your voice - WEAR IT OUT LOUD! merch back in stock! SHOP LIMITED QUANTITIES!

    Record your story @ or our iPhone app for a chance to get animated.

    Nikki and her friend, Lola, loved to play truth or dare with Oreos - a special version of the classic game that made the Oreo decide whether you had to tell the truth or complete a dare. If you pulled apart the Oreo and there was more cream on the side of the cookie in your hand, you had to answer whatever question was asked.

    So, one day, Nikki and Lola were playing the game at the park, and Lola asked Nikki who her crush was. Nikki pulled apart the cookie and was horrified to see that her side of the cookie had more cream. For a second, she thought about lying and making up a fake crush. But, after deciding she could trust Lola, Nikki blurted out her crush's name - Steve. Steve was one of the most popular guys at school.

    Once Nikki had confessed her crush, it was Lola's turn to play the Oreo game and reveal who she liked. Lola pulled apart the Oreo and saw more cream on her side of the cookie. She told Nikki that she had already said her own crush's name, and in that moment, Nikki realized exactly what she was saying - Lola also liked Steve. Without knowing how to handle the news, they both walked home in an awkward silence.

    Later that day, Nikki started to text Steve and they began playing the classic version of truth or dare. When Steve picked truth, Nikki anxiously asked him who his crush was in hopes of him saying her name. However, Steve's answer was not what she hoped for - he responded saying he liked Lola. Nikki was crushed.

    After that, Nikki checked her social media and instagram accounts and was devastated to see pictures of Lola and Steve kissing online. They had practically become a couple overnight.

    Lola and Steve are still dating to this day. When she looks back, it must feel weird for Nikki to say to herself, "My friend and I liked the same guy." However, Nikki's story has a happy ending, too. She is now with a new boy named Sam, and she couldn't be happier.

    What's your true story? storybooth wants to hear it!

    Instagram: @thestorybooth

    If you liked this storybooth storytime (story time storybook) animation watch our themed parity playlist collections full of true stories:

    Being Yourself:

    Love and Heartbreak:

    Embarrassing and Funny:

    Bullies and Mean People:

    Overcoming Challenges:

    #storybooth #noscripts #novoiceactors
  • Movies Movies

Comments • 8 504

  • Golden cookie
    Golden cookie  2 hours back

    That happens to me twice and it hurts so much that my crush like my best friend 😪 but my crush this school year doesn't have a crush with my best friend

    • The day Dreamer
      The day Dreamer  7 hours back

      GG I’m out

      • Üséd Támpöns
        Üséd Támpöns  12 hours back

        All these story booths the voice is so cut out

        • Kiara Cervantes
          Kiara Cervantes  13 hours back

          I think this game is a cheater

          • Red fur Blue
            Red fur Blue  16 hours back

            Oh wow she has the same crush that’s just messed up BOI

            • Phie Mqadi
              Phie Mqadi  21 hours back

              My boyfriend is Steve and everybody likes him... my friend like him

              And this was shared to me by one of my classmates😂😍

              • Carolina Esteban
                Carolina Esteban  21 hours back

                I hate Lola

                • Otaku 993
                  Otaku 993  23 hours back

                  This 2 girls are me and my bestfriend we have the same crush but my crush thinks of me as a friend and my crush thinks of my friend a friend too. But we're still BFF

                  • Rakesh Kshirsagar
                    Rakesh Kshirsagar  1 days back

                    Anyway but I don't think that u must get upset with ur bff due a stunning boy

                    • leons_love_da_world leons 4 life

                      Me and my friend has the same crush as me but we not mad at each other we actually laughed and we were fine lol but good job

                      • Jailia Boi
                        Jailia Boi  2 days back

                        That happened to me to I lost like everything

                        • Skater girl 3000
                          Skater girl 3000  2 days back

                          This is how enemies are made...

                          • Sofia Butini
                            Sofia Butini  2 days back

                            This happened to me and I got the dudes number from the friend and he ask me out and she HATED me for that she told rumors and about me for like 2 days and then we made up and it kinda brought use together more
                            AND THIS HAPPENED WHEN I WAS TEN

                            • Ryelee Gill
                              Ryelee Gill  2 days back

                              She’s a little bleep

                              • Omar Lujano
                                Omar Lujano  2 days back

                                Steve is gay

                                • Kasandra Draws
                                  Kasandra Draws  2 days back

                                  THIS IS WHAT HAPPENED TO MY STEPSISTER

                                  • noob noob
                                    noob noob  2 days back


                                    • Maria_loves__to_dance_107 Contreras

                                      Nikki:I like Steve
                                      Lola:I'm gonna take my horse to the old town road I'm gonna ride till I can't no more

                                      • Lydia Kelli
                                        Lydia Kelli  3 days back


                                        IS THAT TIM FROM BRAINPOP

                                        • BillyTheDailyGamer_ YT

                                          WAS THAT LIL NAS X AND BILLY RAY CYRUS?

                                          • Emiladi Corejo
                                            Emiladi Corejo  3 days back

                                            Is bad word

                                            • 1SENSATION
                                              1SENSATION  3 days back

                                              So we just going to ignore the *Old Time Road* talk 😂

                                              • Eaglefeather 21
                                                Eaglefeather 21  3 days back

                                                Oh no....

                                                *these girls broke girlcode*

                                                • Morgan McCabe
                                                  Morgan McCabe  3 days back

                                                  Don’t lose a friend over a guy..

                                                  • Jimmy 1916 ww1
                                                    Jimmy 1916 ww1  3 days back

                                                    The girl whos is telling the story: i like steve his cool
                                                    Minecraft steve: am i a joke to you

                                                    • Romelyn Tolentino
                                                      Romelyn Tolentino  3 days back

                                                      I don't have some one too

                                                      • Mike Benonie
                                                        Mike Benonie  5 days back

                                                        You should tell Lola that you don't wanna to be friends no more
                                                        Because you like my crush and you stoal him from me because you are
                                                        So prettier than me.
                                                        Say that to Lola and you should be with another guy better than Steve.

                                                        • Addi rae
                                                          Addi rae  5 days back

                                                          So see? This all worked out.

                                                          • {The Not So Normal Potato}

                                                            I thought Steve was with Alex tho😂

                                                            • Its Zoe!
                                                              Its Zoe!  5 days back

                                                              For Halloween why don’t you and Sam dress up like DOUBLE STUFFED OREOS!😁

                                                              • Aishath SHAUFA
                                                                Aishath SHAUFA  5 days back

                                                                This happened to me and my friend
                                                                We 2 were fighting and my crush liked my
                                                                Best friend. I'm broken 😢😢

                                                                • Elijah Kirtley
                                                                  Elijah Kirtley  6 days back

                                                                  She’s vsco

                                                                  • kid A.H.I
                                                                    kid A.H.I  6 days back

                                                                    Umm, this is actually a pretty heart breaking story that *I can't relate to. . . .*

                                                                    Because I only like 2D guys, the ones that aren't real, so, yeah. . . Have fun. .

                                                                    • Bhavya Makkar
                                                                      Bhavya Makkar  6 days back

                                                                      0:42 how dare she throw that Oreo away like that?!

                                                                      • chae luvr
                                                                        chae luvr  6 days back

                                                                        id be so heartbroken if my crush told me he liked my bestfriend

                                                                        • Isaac Garcia
                                                                          Isaac Garcia  6 days back

                                                                          Heheh my real name is sam :3 hehehhehe jk it was a joke k

                                                                          • kate weaver
                                                                            kate weaver  6 days back


                                                                            • kate weaver
                                                                              kate weaver  6 days back


                                                                              • LunarCakess
                                                                                LunarCakess  6 days back

                                                                                OMG THEY LIKE THE KING STEVE HARRINGTON!

                                                                                I mean who can't resist that hair tbh

                                                                                • Janelle Dancel
                                                                                  Janelle Dancel  6 days back

                                                                                  I hate lola UGHHH

                                                                                  • Jony baidya
                                                                                    Jony baidya  6 days back

                                                                                    Steve is a minecraft charecter name

                                                                                    • Drama Llama
                                                                                      Drama Llama  6 days back

                                                                                      It’s funny that an oreo can ruin someone’s life

                                                                                      • Caroline McAuliffe
                                                                                        Caroline McAuliffe  6 days back

                                                                                        “mY cRuSh LeFt Me FoR mY bEsT fRiEnD”

                                                                                        Bruh he wasn’t dating you, he can’t leave you yet 😂

                                                                                      • Mr. TROLOLOLOLOL!!!!
                                                                                        Mr. TROLOLOLOLOL!!!!  6 days back

                                                                                        *Its the Oreo’s fault*

                                                                                        • Didi
                                                                                          Didi  7 days back


                                                                                          Nikki: *ight imma head out*

                                                                                          • StickSkorpion
                                                                                            StickSkorpion  7 days back

                                                                                            Welp it's just life

                                                                                            • Martina G
                                                                                              Martina G  7 days back

                                                                                              This happened to me today... I'm Nikki, but I haven't found anyone

                                                                                              • thatonepinkbomb
                                                                                                thatonepinkbomb  1 weeks back

                                                                                                That's why you crush on nobody