My Friend And I Liked The Same Guy

  • Published: 16 July 2019
  • By Nikki | Subscribe: | Comment, like, share this story.
    Stand up against people who judge others and use your voice - WEAR IT OUT LOUD! merch back in stock! SHOP LIMITED QUANTITIES!

    Record your story @ or our iPhone app for a chance to get animated.

    Nikki and her friend, Lola, loved to play truth or dare with Oreos - a special version of the classic game that made the Oreo decide whether you had to tell the truth or complete a dare. If you pulled apart the Oreo and there was more cream on the side of the cookie in your hand, you had to answer whatever question was asked.

    So, one day, Nikki and Lola were playing the game at the park, and Lola asked Nikki who her crush was. Nikki pulled apart the cookie and was horrified to see that her side of the cookie had more cream. For a second, she thought about lying and making up a fake crush. But, after deciding she could trust Lola, Nikki blurted out her crush's name - Steve. Steve was one of the most popular guys at school.

    Once Nikki had confessed her crush, it was Lola's turn to play the Oreo game and reveal who she liked. Lola pulled apart the Oreo and saw more cream on her side of the cookie. She told Nikki that she had already said her own crush's name, and in that moment, Nikki realized exactly what she was saying - Lola also liked Steve. Without knowing how to handle the news, they both walked home in an awkward silence.

    Later that day, Nikki started to text Steve and they began playing the classic version of truth or dare. When Steve picked truth, Nikki anxiously asked him who his crush was in hopes of him saying her name. However, Steve's answer was not what she hoped for - he responded saying he liked Lola. Nikki was crushed.

    After that, Nikki checked her social media and instagram accounts and was devastated to see pictures of Lola and Steve kissing online. They had practically become a couple overnight.

    Lola and Steve are still dating to this day. When she looks back, it must feel weird for Nikki to say to herself, "My friend and I liked the same guy." However, Nikki's story has a happy ending, too. She is now with a new boy named Sam, and she couldn't be happier.

    What's your true story? storybooth wants to hear it!

    Instagram: @thestorybooth

    If you liked this storybooth storytime (story time storybook) animation watch our themed parity playlist collections full of true stories:

    Being Yourself:

    Love and Heartbreak:

    Embarrassing and Funny:

    Bullies and Mean People:

    Overcoming Challenges:

    #storybooth #noscripts #novoiceactors
  • Movies Movies

Comments • 8 964

  • Cynthia Greer
    Cynthia Greer  1 hours back

    Where the Oreos double stuff?

    • GO Crazy
      GO Crazy  20 hours back

      1:19 talking about old town road

      • yukja ;;
        yukja ;;  23 hours back

        okay this video is so scary. my current crush is named steve and guess what my name is? SAM. this is WACK weird.

        • SIS IS SHOOK
          SIS IS SHOOK  2 days back

          She does know how to lie right

          • Ari Pineda
            Ari Pineda  2 days back

            That’s called a fake friend dude

            • LegoMeng
              LegoMeng  2 days back

              Bruh a boy doesn't like you because ur black what a racist

              • Aline Eglais
                Aline Eglais  3 days back

                Sam and Steve are regular shemgular names everyone has that name

                • Brianna Ramirez
                  Brianna Ramirez  3 days back

                  Them both liking steve

                  Steve:Ahoy Ladies! Didn't see you there😅

                  • Random Person
                    Random Person  4 days back

                    If This happened to me I would not date my crush because he is my friends crush and I wouldn’t wanna make her sad, but my friend called my crush ugly so the chances of her liking him are low

                    • A.r tomboy
                      A.r tomboy  5 days back

                      Don’t let a crush ruined your friendship.

                      • Sam ᄋ다ᅧ Kitty-chan

                        Im Sam ;v; i guessbim nice UwU

                        • Steve
                          Steve  6 days back

                          Yo what

                          • PinkFriday
                            PinkFriday  6 days back

                            I bet they broke up in 2020

                            • •Olihxo•
                              •Olihxo•  6 days back

                              My friend had a friend that liked the same guy who she liked and my friend got the guy because he has a sister and I talked his sister into telling him to make my friend his girlfriend and now their a couple but I'm still lonely 😔😂

                              • Angela Sanchez
                                Angela Sanchez  6 days back

                                girl I'm so sorry but I'm so happy for you because if this didn't happen you wouldn't find the boy you actually liked so good luck in your life I really love the story

                                • Jordan FangZ
                                  Jordan FangZ  7 days back

                                  are u and Lola still friends?????????????????????????????????????????????????

                                  • Fresh Peppers
                                    Fresh Peppers  1 weeks back

                                    My solution is to be a lesbian and your best friend is straight.

                                    • I live over 3000 years Bc I’m trash

                                      :Story booth: ME AND MY FRIEND HAVE THE SAME CRUSH
                                      Army: *never heard of that before*

                                      • Jolly_MB
                                        Jolly_MB  6 days back

                                        lol armyyy💜💜

                                    • lucia papiccio
                                      lucia papiccio  1 weeks back

                                      Lola broke girl code all the way man 😂

                                      • x_br1ght
                                        x_br1ght  1 weeks back

                                        imagine oreos are the reasons your life is destroyed

                                        • Ciara Mills
                                          Ciara Mills  1 weeks back

                                          One of my kinda friends and I like the same guy and my old friends which is still the other girls friend we like him and he dont talk to me no more but he talks to her but thats ok with me because hes rude and tells people I lile him even tho he said he wouldn't but whatever cuz rated 1/10 I loke him 3/10 but my other crush I like him 10/10 and he knows i lile him even tho he dont like me and we are friends😚😁

                                          • Mr. TROLOLOLOLOL!!!!
                                            Mr. TROLOLOLOLOL!!!!  1 weeks back

                                            The oreo they have is cursed

                                            • Joselin Guadarrama
                                              Joselin Guadarrama  1 weeks back

                                              I kinda hate lola so much i hope her heart brokes yea sorry but i felt bad for you and yea sorry lola not for you steve becuase you and steve look si cute together

                                              • Mekhia Jordyn vlog
                                                Mekhia Jordyn vlog  1 weeks back

                                                That’s what happen to me

                                                • Luminous X
                                                  Luminous X  1 weeks back

                                                  *Nobody is wondering what happens to the Oreos....*

                                                  • moesvideos1030
                                                    moesvideos1030  1 weeks back

                                                    Why does he look like Minecraft Steve?

                                                    • Claudia' s vlogs
                                                      Claudia' s vlogs  1 weeks back

                                                      Me and my BEST friend like the same person and we're fine with it we're fine if one of us date him we even said we would be proud of each other for dating him and having confidents

                                                      • Pinkfluffy Starlight
                                                        Pinkfluffy Starlight  1 weeks back

                                                        I'm glad it's a happy ending

                                                        • Cloudy Tears
                                                          Cloudy Tears  2 weeks back

                                                          Awwwww cute💕😍

                                                          • Cloudy Tears
                                                            Cloudy Tears  2 weeks back

                                                            Awwww poor heart broken girl😭💔

                                                            • Cloudy Tears
                                                              Cloudy Tears  2 weeks back

                                                              I felt that😝🤓🤩

                                                              • The Adventuresome Life of Addi

                                                                My Girlfriends Like My Crush Dominion

                                                                • Rainb0w_ Bl4de
                                                                  Rainb0w_ Bl4de  2 weeks back

                                                                  Damn it Stevie!

                                                                  (Smosh fans will know)

                                                                  • vanessa avalos
                                                                    vanessa avalos  2 weeks back

                                                                    My crush's name is steve too😳😭

                                                                    • Charles Crutchfield
                                                                      Charles Crutchfield  2 weeks back

                                                                      I have a daughter named lula

                                                                      • Swarali Deshpande
                                                                        Swarali Deshpande  2 weeks back

                                                                        There was this one time me and my other 2 frnds liked a guy at the same time

                                                                        • Sherlin Jacobo
                                                                          Sherlin Jacobo  2 weeks back

                                                                          This is not even how you play truth or dare😂😂😭😭

                                                                          • just passing by
                                                                            just passing by  2 weeks back

                                                                            When I clicked on this video an ad started playing [CarGurus Ad] and it said "This is Steve,"

                                                                            • MiMi Gacha
                                                                              MiMi Gacha  2 weeks back

                                                                              Is lola was a real friend, she wouldnt hurt her friend’s feelings😡 she should have said no and explained why or at least not post it on social media

                                                                              • ROBLOX wolf boy
                                                                                ROBLOX wolf boy  2 weeks back


                                                                                • Treble the dog
                                                                                  Treble the dog  2 weeks back

                                                                                  1:01 watch your mouth girl cus that janitor is mah man

                                                                                  • xxRaveCrystalsxx 123
                                                                                    xxRaveCrystalsxx 123  2 weeks back

                                                                                    her: so i have a friend
                                                                                    me: *cant relate.*

                                                                                  • Kubanthri Govender
                                                                                    Kubanthri Govender  2 weeks back


                                                                                    • Nalani Cox
                                                                                      Nalani Cox  2 weeks back

                                                                                      I know it's kinda wrong to date your best friends crush or there ex but if you like him and he likes you then..... 😬😬 obviously you should date him

                                                                                      • Gloria Murray
                                                                                        Gloria Murray  2 weeks back

                                                                                        How it's starts 😊 the middle 😦 the end😏

                                                                                        • Nevaeh Rodriguez
                                                                                          Nevaeh Rodriguez  2 weeks back


                                                                                          • Rose Delgado-Arias
                                                                                            Rose Delgado-Arias  3 weeks back

                                                                                            Now you and Lola are even

                                                                                            • •C o d a_Yeet •
                                                                                              •C o d a_Yeet •  3 weeks back

                                                                                              I wish my crush liked me back ;-;