Film Theory: Did Rick CLONE Beth - SOLVED! (Rick and Morty)

Share
HTML-code

Comments • 41 576

  • The Film Theorists
    The Film Theorists   2 years back

    I cut this out of the episode, but I'm seeing this question show up in the comments, so let me clarify:

    - The clock in the garage is ALWAYS stuck at that time in every scene you see it, at least in this episode. So the time it reads can't be used as a part of putting together an accurate timeline of events. Good job looking out for it, though!

    • Subliminal Lover
      Subliminal Lover  7 days back

      Holy shit 499 comment. If I am not wrong 500 was the limit. Let’s test it.
      Sorry for ruining the latest comment. I just had to test it

    • ONTO
      ONTO  4 weeks back

      🙃

    • Nathan Alexander
      Nathan Alexander  2 months back

      Why can't he have driven the car through a portal on the way back from the jail

    • Yang Feng
      Yang Feng  2 months back

      I’m sure there were daylight outside at 10pm midsummer(because it’s actually 9pm, daylight saving thing).

    • Steveasaurus Birkett
      Steveasaurus Birkett  2 months back

      my thoughts exactly

  • christian DONLEY
    christian DONLEY  13 hours back

    Was beth always a clone from the start of the show how can we know if she is or isn't the "real beth"

    • Tony
      Tony  22 hours back

      Most weekend visitation starts on Fridays after school is over.

      • Kael’s Gaming world
        Kael’s Gaming world  1 days back

        Real

        • Somebody Somewhere
          Somebody Somewhere  1 days back

          I ALWAYS considered this idea after watching that episode. Thank you for covering this, Matt!

          • Nickson Emmanuel
            Nickson Emmanuel  1 days back

            Clone

            • Tick _Tick
              Tick _Tick  1 days back

              4:24 ahem there is a clock in the backround

              • rj ragas
                rj ragas  2 days back

                Shes both real AND fake (its a reference)

                • Freshairkaboom Gaming
                  Freshairkaboom Gaming  2 days back

                  real

                  • Terrance Strickland
                    Terrance Strickland  2 days back

                    Y wouldn't the real beth remember her childhood

                    • FAKE name
                      FAKE name  2 days back

                      i love that there we're pizzas on the counter

                      • American Idiot920
                        American Idiot920  2 days back

                        Clone at first now real

                        • Landon Boykin
                          Landon Boykin  2 days back

                          Real

                          • Awkward Hooman being
                            Awkward Hooman being  2 days back

                            Hi so I have a theory maybe she was acting strange and affectionate was because the clone wasn’t done yet, so she was just been sweet and loving because she was about to leave her family

                            • galaxy 12345678910
                              galaxy 12345678910  2 days back

                              Clone

                              • Kenneth Baker
                                Kenneth Baker  3 days back

                                Real

                                • OneBrickAtATime
                                  OneBrickAtATime  3 days back

                                  real

                                  • Barnacle 12
                                    Barnacle 12  3 days back

                                    Wow! Big brain 🧠

                                    • Robyn Gundlach
                                      Robyn Gundlach  3 days back

                                      Fake because she could've been cloned before when she was in her child hood place

                                      • jianwei lee
                                        jianwei lee  4 days back

                                        unless beth was cloned way before and rick anticipated it hence his travel pitch

                                        • leinaD PQ
                                          leinaD PQ  4 days back

                                          RICK AND MORTY TRAVEL TO ANOTHER DIMENSION WHICH MAKES BETH A CLONE

                                          • Ruby Dunn
                                            Ruby Dunn  4 days back

                                            Real

                                            • LethalKaos
                                              LethalKaos  4 days back

                                              Real

                                              • Carlie Johnson
                                                Carlie Johnson  4 days back

                                                Real

                                                • Unamed_conedian
                                                  Unamed_conedian  4 days back

                                                  Real

                                                  • Gavin Mullins
                                                    Gavin Mullins  4 days back

                                                    Real

                                                    • Kryptic kan
                                                      Kryptic kan  5 days back

                                                      This is a solid theory but you didnt take into account that there is a box labeled "time travel stuff" in on his shelves in the garage. This shows that rick is fully capable of altering time. Even in the clip of an interview you used at 6:46 the idea of time travel has been proven to be in their thoughts. Therefore they could introduce time travel into the new season coming November 2019.

                                                      • Tim Time
                                                        Tim Time  5 days back

                                                        That's the joke I think, the idea of time travel has literally been shelved.

                                                    • Austin Kramer
                                                      Austin Kramer  5 days back

                                                      At 18:17 in the actual episode Beth and rick are talking about cloning her, behind the cloning chamber it shows a clock that says its 2 o'clock, so if they cloned her, it would only be 5 o'clock.

                                                      • Stephen J
                                                        Stephen J  5 days back

                                                        Clone

                                                        • Jonathan Steed
                                                          Jonathan Steed  6 days back

                                                          Beth is clone as she doesn't remember her decision to become a clone or not. Granted Rick can erase memory's he wouldn't waste the time on clearing a clones memory if it only left a open ended question Meaning "work". The real Beth asked for Rick to remove her answer to ensure her clone would take the time to verify her place in her family. Trust but verify to entrust operations are covered correctly. Its a managers tool after all.

                                                          • Neon Lightz
                                                            Neon Lightz  6 days back

                                                            Wait wait wait. Rick doesn’t drive a car

                                                            • Ray Whitmire
                                                              Ray Whitmire  6 days back

                                                              I've never doubted that she's the same Beth as the beginning of the episode.
                                                              I question if she's a clone of another Beth who caught the same offer and TOOK IT!

                                                              • Hazy Dee
                                                                Hazy Dee  6 days back

                                                                Real

                                                                • Roader 7204
                                                                  Roader 7204  7 days back

                                                                  real

                                                                  • Ibrahim Altamimi
                                                                    Ibrahim Altamimi  7 days back

                                                                    Real

                                                                    • Deltangell Gaming
                                                                      Deltangell Gaming  7 days back

                                                                      Real

                                                                      • Peepee Poopoo
                                                                        Peepee Poopoo  7 days back

                                                                        Real

                                                                        • Stephen Napoleon
                                                                          Stephen Napoleon  7 days back

                                                                          Real. Her behavior around Rick at the end of the episode is plausible to me and MatPat's proof just forget cements what my I already believe.

                                                                          • Krish Bhardwaj
                                                                            Krish Bhardwaj  7 days back

                                                                            Real

                                                                            • Koby Pruett
                                                                              Koby Pruett  1 weeks back

                                                                              whose to say that she didn't stay till the kids went to bed and then leave in the middle of the night, that would explain why rick was being so nice cuz he knew she was leaving.

                                                                              • Joseph Camp
                                                                                Joseph Camp  1 weeks back

                                                                                Dont forget about the pause button that Rick uses to clean up after the wild party. It doesn't time travel it stops time.

                                                                                • Rocket Point
                                                                                  Rocket Point  1 weeks back

                                                                                  Couldn't Rick just dimension hop and grab some other beth since there has to be one that doesn't know about ricks experiments?

                                                                                  • Tyron Dupont
                                                                                    Tyron Dupont  1 weeks back

                                                                                    Plot twist Rick already had a clone ready all along

                                                                                    • Lubos Ondrik
                                                                                      Lubos Ondrik  1 weeks back

                                                                                      You literally just have to think. If rick has the power to manipulate memories (which we know he has becouse of the previous episode) why would he leave the memory of the choice of wanting to leave/stay also he said it has 0% chance of going blade runner so she is definitly not a clone or the writers didnt really think this one through

                                                                                      • Mir Allan Dogan
                                                                                        Mir Allan Dogan  1 weeks back

                                                                                        What if rick all ready a clone in the first place??

                                                                                        • DO GE
                                                                                          DO GE  1 weeks back

                                                                                          WOOF

                                                                                          • Susan Labenz
                                                                                            Susan Labenz  1 weeks back

                                                                                            REAL!

                                                                                            • tHeOnEAnDoNLyD/-/ I L AN

                                                                                              Real