REAL Pumpkin Pie Taste Test

  • Published: 23 October 2019
  • Did you know that most pumpkin pie doesn't actually have pumpkin in it?! Today, we're trying the REAL DEAL in today's Good Mythical More, the show AFTER the show!  GMMORE #1622
    Subscribe to GMMORE:

    Watch today's GMM:
    Click the bell icon so you'll know when we add a new episode!

    Want more GMMORE? Check out this playlist:Good Mythical More | Summer 2019:
    Season 15 -

    Pick up official GMM and Mythical merch at

    Don’t miss our weekly podcast, Ear Biscuits:

    Join the Mythical Society:

    Follow Rhett & Link: 

    Check Out Our Other Mythical Channels:
    Good Mythical Morning:

    bmit your Wheel of Mythicality intro video here:

    Intro Animation by Dana Schechter
    Intro & Outro Music by Mark Byers
    Supplemental Music from Extreme Production Music:
    Mic: ‘The Mouse’ by Blue Microphones

    Get the GMM Set Gear!
    * Apple AirPort Extreme:
    * Apple iPad Pro (12.9-inch, Wi-Fi, 64GB) - Space Gray (Latest Model) - MTEL2LL/A:
    * Guardian Industrial Products DH-CP-4 3 Channel Rubber Cable Ramp (Straight):
    * Cartoni Focus HD Fluid Head with 3 Tube Ultra-Light Tripod, Mid-Level Spreader and Soft Case - Black:
    * ARRI SkyPanel S60-C LED Softlight (Blue/Silver, Edison):
    * Chef-Master 90050 Professional Heat Lamp, Silver:
    * Samsung UN40H5003 40-Inch 1080p LED TV (2014 Model):
    * Sony LMDA170 17" Production Video LCD Monitor, 16:9 Native Aspect Ratio, 1080p Resolution:
    * Behringer Xenyx 1002 Premium 10-Input 2-Bus Mixer with XENYX Mic Preamps and British Eqs:
    * Elgato Game Capture Card HD60 S - Stream and Record in 1080p60, for PlayStation 4, Xbox One & Xbox 360 (Renewed):
    * Pyle Universal Speaker Stand Mount Holder - Heavy Duty Tripod w/ Adjustable Height from 40” to 71” and 35mm Compatible Insert - Easy Mobility Safety PIN and Knob Tension Locking for Stability PSTND2:
    * JBL EON612 Portable 12" 2-Way Multipurpose Self-Powered Sound Reinforcement:
    * Bolt 500 XT 3G-SDI/HDMI Wireless TX/RX:
    * Voigtlaender 17,5/0,95 Nokton 17.5 mm-17.5 mm Lens:
    * Blackmagic Design Micro Converter SDI to HDMI (with Power Supply) BMD-CONVCMIC/SH/WPSU:
    * Panasonic H-HSA35100 F2.8 II ASPH 35-100mm Mirrorless Micro Four Thirds Mount POWER Optical I.S. LUMIX G X VARIO Professional Lens:
    * PANASONIC LUMIX Professional 12-35mm Camera Lens G X VARIO II, F2.8 ASPH, Dual I.S. 2.0 with Power O.I.S., Mirrorless Micro Four Thirds, H-HSA12035 (2017 Model, Black):
    * Decimator Design DMON-12S | 12 Channel Multi Viewer with HDMI SDI Outputs:
    * Decimator MD-HX HDMI and SDI Cross Converter with Scaling & Frame Rate Conversion:
    * PANASONIC LUMIX GH4 Body 4K Mirrorless Camera, 16 Megapixels, 3 Inch Touch LCD, DMC-GH4KBODY (USA Black):
    * Blue Microphones Mouse Microphone Kc:
  • Entertainment Entertainment

Comments • 904

  • Jill Kealling
    Jill Kealling  2 weeks back

    kabocha squash is the best squash. I stand with the japanese restaurants calling it pumpkin.

      CAPTAIN8INSANE [Æ]  4 weeks back


      • Michael Westbrook
        Michael Westbrook  1 months back


        • burntappleslice
          burntappleslice  1 months back

          how come link's kind of scottish/irish accent kind sounded like robins williams mrs doubtfire

          • here2watch08
            here2watch08  1 months back

            Dickinson Squash is also colloquially known as a Crookneck or Dickinson PUMPKIN. So there IS Pumpkin in Pumpkin Pie, it's just not a Field Pumpkin. It's literally people's opinions that are perpetuating this notion that Pumpkin Pie contains no Pumpkin since there is no FDA definition of a Pumpkin. If it's known at all to people as a Pumpkin, it's a Pumpkin then. Also, Pumpkins ARE squashes, so a Squash Pie is just as much a Pumpkin Pie because a Pumpkin Pie is also a Squash Pie. Leave Libby alone!😂

            • Jason Lawnicak
              Jason Lawnicak  1 months back

              Use Sugar Pumpkins.

              • Charles Miller
                Charles Miller  1 months back

                You need a sugar pumpkin to make a pumpkin pie!

                • Nightshade Kelly
                  Nightshade Kelly  1 months back

                  Thanks for the monologue Link

                  • RA Gibby
                    RA Gibby  1 months back

                    Why does Link have to hold, touch, control everything? Just set it down (whatever it is) and let Rhett get his own bites.

                    • KenzieHurlock
                      KenzieHurlock  1 months back

                      There's a thing called a pie pumpkin which is smaller and it tastes good. I've had it.

                      • Dama Lewis
                        Dama Lewis  1 months back

                        Nice idea, but you don’t use carving pumpkins for pumpkin pie! You use a pie pumpkin, and it’s incredibly delicious.

                        • kamo of dresden
                          kamo of dresden  1 months back

                          Rhett cut a piece of pie left it and took the rest😂😂😂 7:41

                          • Tfhi Gfrth
                            Tfhi Gfrth  1 months back

                            Say “pumpkin” 10 times
                            It’s a weird word ain’t it

                            • Christine C.
                              Christine C.  1 months back

                              Most words are weird if you repeat them enough.

                          • Kimberly Smith
                            Kimberly Smith  1 months back

                            My mom uses pie pumpkins to make pumpkin pie all the time for the fall. We never use pumpkin puree but what!

                            • QuartyDawn
                              QuartyDawn  1 months back

                              Guess this an American thing. The popular canned pumpkin that most people I know use here in Canada has one single ingredient. Pumpkin. I've had homemade pumpkin pie made from an actual roasted pumpkin, store bought, etc. and they all have a similar taste. So I guess here in Canada we use actual pumpkins lol

                              • Manax Plumbing
                                Manax Plumbing  1 months back

                                I can't say Link's attempt at being an old Pilgrim was worth the time fill it made... :/

                                • Laura Beaulieu
                                  Laura Beaulieu  1 months back

                                  Shouldn’t josh know about sugar pumpkins.....

                                  • Larry Walling
                                    Larry Walling  1 months back

                                    REAL PUMPKIN PIE. GOOD JOB 😎

                                    • Inpowr Gaming
                                      Inpowr Gaming  1 months back

                                      My future children is watching 😂😂😂😂

                                      • Sari J
                                        Sari J  1 months back

                                        As a non-American, I've always found it strange anyone would want pumpkin in their pie. But it also might be because I've had pickled pumpkin.

                                        • Brian Geary
                                          Brian Geary  1 months back

                                          Link is just too much now. I feel like hes trying way to hard as opposed to 2 - 3 years ago he was just funny.

                                          • Saroyan Dynamite
                                            Saroyan Dynamite  1 months back

                                            In Spanish there isn't a word for pumpkin, we just call everything squash

                                            • Dezsii Faye
                                              Dezsii Faye  1 months back

                                              Josh should've used a pie pumpkin

                                              • Ellen Spear
                                                Ellen Spear  1 months back

                                                Why so much dithering? Please just get down to the subject I clicked on this vid to see.

                                                • Sheri Racine
                                                  Sheri Racine  1 months back

                                                  When I was a kid we just called it a sugar pumpkin

                                                  • Rose50Reno
                                                    Rose50Reno  1 months back

                                                    Try using a sweet pumpkin which is grown for fresh pumpkin pies.
                                                    Field pumpkins are grown for the jack-o-lantern making.
                                                    Get your google machines a working boys. Your a bit weak on your research.

                                                    • MariaVana
                                                      MariaVana  1 months back

                                                      For Josh: Fenugreek has been scientifically proven to be the most desirable flavor for horses... score one for my equine science degree =]

                                                      • Mandi Nicole
                                                        Mandi Nicole  1 months back

                                                        When I make homemade pumpkin pie I use sugar pumpkins, they are sweeter and tastier that “jackolantern” pumpkins.

                                                        • Alpaca O Doom
                                                          Alpaca O Doom  1 months back

                                                          Field pumpkins aren't meant to be eaten the other type of pumpkin is also pumpkin species but tastes better I'm a professional chef before anyone says they know more

                                                          • Belle Stewart LVT
                                                            Belle Stewart LVT  1 months back

                                                            Fenugreek is a spice that makes up curry

                                                            • Laura g
                                                              Laura g  1 months back

                                                              You have to use a 'pie pumpkin,' which is smaller and is much sweeter than a field pumpkin

                                                              • Gideon Friedman
                                                                Gideon Friedman  1 months back

                                                                You are my favorite youtubers

                                                                • Blaine Trarop
                                                                  Blaine Trarop  1 months back

                                                                  Anise is in pumpkin spice.

                                                                  • Bubby Adams
                                                                    Bubby Adams  1 months back

                                                                    Wow, you are suppose to use Cinderella pumpkins make home made pumpkin 🥧 pie. One good size Cinderella pumpkin can make about 15 pumpkin pies. I surprised Josh doesn't know this???🤨

                                                                    • Sam R
                                                                      Sam R  1 months back

                                                                      There are actual dessert pumpkins that are better for pumpkin pies

                                                                      • AnimeCanuck
                                                                        AnimeCanuck  1 months back

                                                                        The REAL pumpkin pie looks like pumpkin pies in Canada - even most of the store-bought ones. Probably the most common pumpkin pie filling up here is E.D. Smith's canned pumpkin (filling?). E.D. Smith is a "fancier" jam company... usually right next to Smuckers' for a couple dollars more. As soon as Link cut into that I thought "mmm... that looks GOOD."

                                                                        • harm van zon
                                                                          harm van zon  1 months back

                                                                          It's a language thing. In Holland a butternut squach is called (freely translated) Bottle Pumpkin. So you would make a pie with pumpkin

                                                                          • hey ewe
                                                                            hey ewe  1 months back

                                                                            I made pumpkin pie from fresh pumpkins. It was quite yummy. I used a small pumpkin because if you use a large pumpkin you have more pumpkin than any human needs at one time.

                                                                            • Fade2 blacK
                                                                              Fade2 blacK  1 months back

                                                                              Link leans in for a kiss? 3:04

                                                                              • Gillian Ekins
                                                                                Gillian Ekins  1 months back

                                                                                ... you know there's something called a pie pumpkin... right?

                                                                                • Cameron Sauter
                                                                                  Cameron Sauter  1 months back

                                                                                  Wtf was that story

                                                                                  • Ken OKeefe
                                                                                    Ken OKeefe  1 months back

                                                                                    Loved Link's soliloquy

                                                                                    • Kazues
                                                                                      Kazues  1 months back

                                                                                      Half the time on this show I think Rhett is just thinking about how rediculous what they are doing is. New selfy face is a prime example.

                                                                                      • Aylisha Brown
                                                                                        Aylisha Brown  1 months back

                                                                                        I prefer squash anyway.

                                                                                        • Talia Voider
                                                                                          Talia Voider  1 months back

                                                                                          Josh is so hot. 😂

                                                                                          • Becca
                                                                                            Becca  1 months back

                                                                                            Why is Link so moody lately?

                                                                                            • Superman Batman
                                                                                              Superman Batman  1 months back

                                                                                              I make my pumpkin pie with real pumpkin

                                                                                              • Dr. Leonard Hofstadter SAVAGE FAM

                                                                                                If they come to me in a form of a pie😂