Robert Downey Jr. Responds to Martin Scorsese’s Criticism of Marvel Movies

Share
HTML-code

Comments • 4 360

  • Kristan Mithos
    Kristan Mithos  5 hours back

    Don t crowd ouT,honest..Cinema

    • Mad King
      Mad King  18 hours back

      Dude, It's martin Scorcese If Stephan Hawking/Einstein tells you that your work is not scientifical. You fucking take it.

      • jason Coffelt
        jason Coffelt  22 hours back

        He meant that marvel is shot after shot of imposible un realistic action insulting the universe of laws of nature.

        • Ronald A. Heinrich
          Ronald A. Heinrich  1 days back

          The Academy recognizes great acting in superhero movies, Heath Ledger as Joker was such a performance. Downeys performance as Iron Man was surely great without doubt, but it was Downey Jr. playing as Downey Jr. as Iron Man. Like Charlie Sheen playing Charlie Sheen in "Two and a half men" as uncle Charlie. Great, funny, a perfect match for that character but no stellar performance as an actor standing for itself.

          • That Nammah Dawg
            That Nammah Dawg  1 days back

            the bruce lee shirt is the same he wore in the avengers?!?

            • Welcome Friends
              Welcome Friends  1 days back

              "therapiest" ...WTF RDJ?

              • TheFly212
                TheFly212  2 days back

                lol, RDJ knows it's not cinema. RDJ prior to this MCU thing was actually a real actor, who took the craft very seriously and actually was once upon a time a method actor. RDJ is just keeping his bank account in check. Disney has made him a mega millionaire. As if he's really gonna give anything other than pro MCU, pro Disney answers. As if.

                • truewolf
                  truewolf  2 days back

                  RDJ is a cool guy but in Iron Man he's just himself. In Sherlock Holmes he is himself. Both characters act the same. Marvel Studio movies teach nothing. There's no point at the end. Sam Raimi's Spider-Man movies and Ang Lee's Hulk 2003 had depth. Marvel Studios movies have non. At the end everybody wins.

                  • idklol
                    idklol  2 days back

                    Saying Scorsese is jealous of Marvel is like saying a star chef is jealous of McDonald's.

                    • Dan99 L
                      Dan99 L  2 days back

                      Scorsese is absolutely right. Is "White Chicks" cinema? Is "Ernest Goes to Jail" cinema? Is "Not Another Teen Movie" cinema? No, fuck no. You can call them movies or flicks, but I do not think they deserve the title of "cinema". They are mass appeal consumerist garbage intended to entertain the most common denominator of our societies.

                      • Releveur 2
                        Releveur 2  2 days back

                        "It's not cinema" is simply an hyperbole which underlines his opinion that the Marvel movies are very bad. Does he think the same thing about the Star Wars movies?

                        • C. B. Alan
                          C. B. Alan  2 days back

                          Did Howard Stern get his face replaced by a microphone? Where's his faaaaaaaccee?

                          • LagLog _
                            LagLog _  2 days back

                            Geez people are so fucking sensitive. If Martin Scorsese wasn't anyone famous and he said these same exact statements no one would give a shit.

                            • Thanduxolo Nelisiwe
                              Thanduxolo Nelisiwe  3 days back

                              Someday we will have to explain why RDJ hasn't been nominated for an Oscar for Iron Man. Some day.

                              • John Williamson
                                John Williamson  3 days back

                                What he meant was the Marvel movies aren't high art, they're popcorn movies made to be fun, not profound or pertinant in any relevant sense. They aren't going to be studied in film schools at any point.

                                • Markus
                                  Markus  3 days back

                                  joker (a scorcese project) is better than avengers endgame

                                  • FractalPrism
                                    FractalPrism  3 days back

                                    howard sternly turns the screws
                                    robert turns it down for jr on the mic
                                    says i have no dog in this fight, no sir, i wont bite

                                    • Michael Di Filippo
                                      Michael Di Filippo  3 days back

                                      Martin is just bummed he's not as relevant anymore. People make what people want to see in the theaters. There is a reason house hold names don't exist anymore because the industry has gotten so much larger than any one person. Even Lucas has to give away his legacy.

                                      • Sight Field
                                        Sight Field  3 days back

                                        THIS IS THE LAD EVERYONE !!! LOVE YOU 3000

                                        • Alex S.
                                          Alex S.  3 days back

                                          Is RDJ just cool or the biggest diplomat on earth?

                                          • Silver Skateboarder
                                            Silver Skateboarder  4 days back

                                            i dunno martin has a point alot of these movies dont capture you...most of the problem is the oversaturated CG effects that ruin the overall appeal and make the movie age like a rotting wine. look at all the movies where they focus on the characters emotions certain scenes and musical scores...can anyone remember or hum the theme to iron man? dont even remember it although iron man was the better out of the marvel movies.

                                            • matthew ivan panes
                                              matthew ivan panes  4 days back

                                              Just wondering why martin scorsese did not give any comments on George Lucas’s Star Wars... as not a “cinema”....duh...

                                              • Unreal Violet
                                                Unreal Violet  4 days back

                                                The interviewer seems more offended by it than RDJ 😂 the whole time he has been nice while HS sounds a bit like he is instigating something.

                                                • Real DOOM COCK
                                                  Real DOOM COCK  4 days back

                                                  I want to see Scorsese's Batman.

                                                  • Joan Ruiz Jacob
                                                    Joan Ruiz Jacob  4 days back

                                                    Martin meant that too much CGI is not cinema. He meant exactly that, but the way he expressed himself was poor.

                                                    • Chad and Jillian Hicks

                                                      Respect and lots of it, towards RDJ, Howard and Martin. Dialogue, view points, no sjw!

                                                      • Éire-ice36
                                                        Éire-ice36  4 days back

                                                        RDJ is responding to the criticism of Scorsese like everybody else should have. Instead too many egotisitical people got their fefes hurt because of they were not mature enough to take an opinionated critic on the chin.


                                                        Also. Howard Stern is as always trying to stir shit up, dude quit it. RDJ has more reason to be mad at Scorsese's critic and he's not offended at all by it.

                                                        • Simoun O'Brien
                                                          Simoun O'Brien  4 days back

                                                          RDJ is a legend. How he handled Scorsese's comments is just pure class.

                                                          • Mark McAllister
                                                            Mark McAllister  5 days back

                                                            No, it's not called "magnanimous" when you are beating around the bush, trying to stay polite with your other rich buddies. Magnanimity is when you have your boot on your enemy's neck, ready to cleave their head from said neck...and then you give mercy. Magnanimity is not authentic until your enemy is prostrate before you, and you give mercy.

                                                            • J 878778
                                                              J 878778  5 days back

                                                              Watch the film 'Chef' by Jon Favreau.

                                                              It is a thinly-veiled critique at the soulless, unartistic, factory-line, test-marketed, populist, commercial way Marvel approach movies. It's Favreau's explanation why he could no longer direct movies for Marvel. It explains why Edgar Wright couldn't, and why, they laregely can't attract any actual directing talent, only yes-men looking for a paycheck for 'overseeing' the movie.

                                                              Scorcese isn't saying a superhero movie can't be art or can't be cinema. He's saying a movie being made by committee, without an individual voice behind it, can't be art.

                                                              The same people who say video games are art would probably agree that a poker machine isn't art. They wouldn't consider someone who microwaves frozen food to be a chef. They can see the same divide between art and decoration, pulp and literature etc. etc.

                                                              • Strange Brew
                                                                Strange Brew  5 days back

                                                                I was just thinking about that yesterday when I played a blue ray dvd of Apocalypse Now and could not believe the absolute artistry of that movie and what absolute crap Movies like Avengers Endgame are and that what a waste of time and money they are.
                                                                Crap, crap, crap and more crap.
                                                                Russo brothers should do something else like selling aluminum siding.

                                                                • Larkin Paculan
                                                                  Larkin Paculan  5 days back

                                                                  Love his DJ Bruce Lee shirt!

                                                                  • Brendan. http://www.Gab.com/brendanday43

                                                                    It not art He meant art it’s technically cinema.. but not as discerning viewers class these movies as

                                                                    • Brendan. http://www.Gab.com/brendanday43

                                                                      Tarantino is right about digital as Martin is on marvel

                                                                      • Brendan. http://www.Gab.com/brendanday43

                                                                        Robert .. just because you weren’t in his movies. Martin is right it’s not cinematic . All movies play in cinema but aren’t cinematic

                                                                        • nihilistman
                                                                          nihilistman  5 days back

                                                                          Classy response as expected. Despite Howard's baiting.

                                                                          • Tywon
                                                                            Tywon  5 days back

                                                                            Scorsese movies are like good food and wine, Marvel moviess are like McDonalds.

                                                                            • Skcyte
                                                                              Skcyte  5 days back

                                                                              Geezus man. Chill host. Asking someone's opinion what it meant to someone else is somewhat nutty IMO.

                                                                              • Rakesh Menon
                                                                                Rakesh Menon  5 days back

                                                                                the presenter is dumb with his logic that RDJ isn't nominated for portraying Iron Man. Good lord, Taxi Driver didn't win an Oscar for being R rated, you dumbo. And rather to the Academy, what do you expect when a guy is killed, milk or water to flow out of his body?

                                                                                • Jack Demiurg
                                                                                  Jack Demiurg  6 days back

                                                                                  Its not cinema in meaning its nothing inventive its over and over the same thing: superhero/optional struggles/ saving world THE END

                                                                                  • Dev Joshi
                                                                                    Dev Joshi  6 days back

                                                                                    Martin would be more pissed off at the host's comments than RDJ's

                                                                                    • Mirrorwarrior
                                                                                      Mirrorwarrior  6 days back

                                                                                      Pretty chill guy! Not many people will have the grace to take an insult to their work so calmly and openly. People can digest insults against themselves but not against their loved ones or their work which they take pride on. This shows character!

                                                                                      • Scott Halloween
                                                                                        Scott Halloween  1 weeks back

                                                                                        Opinions are a lot like assholes, everybody has one, and most of them stink.

                                                                                        • YouTuberUK
                                                                                          YouTuberUK  1 weeks back

                                                                                          Maybe Scorsese was getting at the CGI element of a lot of these movies.....? Where the REAL actors only actually appear for 25% of the movie....
                                                                                          The later transformer movies must have spent 90% of their budget on moving part effects that are just a wasted BLUR (quite literally unwatchable) when viewed on screen.... IMHO...
                                                                                          PS I'm a big sci-fi fan from the 60's when Xmen were originally prof x, jean gray, Cyclops, beast, iceman, and Angel (guy with big wings...)...... :-)

                                                                                          • Harshaan Gill
                                                                                            Harshaan Gill  1 weeks back

                                                                                            Well played mr. Stark.

                                                                                            • Split Dimension
                                                                                              Split Dimension  1 weeks back

                                                                                              Thank you RDJ. Like who cares, right? Let's call it what it is. Scorsese doesn't like those movies. If he takes jab at it and we don't know if its jealously or not, maybe just leave it alone.
                                                                                              We all like movies. We all think RDJ deserves an award for his performance in that character. But the fact that Fans adore him since this role and talk about it constantly, for me that's reward enough. That people like the work I did.
                                                                                              ......and I completely forgot about what Scorsese said because I'm just thinking about how amazing these movies are and how I enjoyed them. At this point, no one else coming out of the same theater and same movie as me that didn't like it, is a person I am not going to talk to. I rather talk with someone who shares my interest.

                                                                                              • jsun Proter
                                                                                                jsun Proter  2 weeks back

                                                                                                Love rdj! This dudes such a politician. He didn't need to steer the conversation in the direction about Scorsese but he did. Then later acts like he's okay with it. the fact that he brought it up till suggests that he's not. For what it's worth I think scorsese's wrong and I love Scorsese films

                                                                                                • daulton gordon
                                                                                                  daulton gordon  2 weeks back

                                                                                                  Cinema is not the "Content" It Is Community, Place and Delivery,