A Simple Math Problem Causes Viral Online Debate | The Daily Show with Trevor Noah

Share
HTML-code

Comments • 4 731

  • Aaditya Aggarwal
    Aaditya Aggarwal  19 hours back

    No wonder we have more cars on the road than needed when half the ppl are giving an answer 16 times the correct one!

    • lsamoa
      lsamoa  1 days back

      The only accurate answer to that math problem is "problem incorrectly stated". Whether the bracket is dividing or multiplying number 8 is unclear as the wrong division sign is used. There's no place for such ambiguity in math. You need to us / and then add a * before the bracket if the answer is supposed to be 16, or just use / if the answer is supposed to be 1. But never ÷ in any math problem statement involving more than two numbers. Basic stuff.

      • Sunday Lee
        Sunday Lee  2 days back

        One

        • Muhammad
          Muhammad  2 days back

          According to the majority, it's 16.
          According to what people say here, it's 1.
          Because in 8÷2(2+2) you do the brackets first. Which gives 8÷2(4). Then, you multiply 2 with 4 because of the brackets which gives 8÷8. When is 1.
          8÷2(2+2)
          8÷2(4)
          8÷8
          1

          Edit: BODMAS starts with Brackets and that means Brackets go first
          And what I was taught is that although brackets do the same thing as multiplication, they aren't the same because brackets go first.

          • Anuj Chitale
            Anuj Chitale  8 hours back

            @Lo Kä Oh.

          • Lo Kä
            Lo Kä  15 hours back

            @Anuj Chitale Can add some webpage to this http://mathforum.org/dr.math/faq/faq.order.operations.html

          • Lo Kä
            Lo Kä  15 hours back

            @Anuj Chitale Math classes and programming courses maybe . I imagine I heard something like this. Source unclear.

          • Anuj Chitale
            Anuj Chitale  15 hours back

            @Lo Kä Who told you this?

          • Lo Kä
            Lo Kä  1 days back

            8:2(4) is 16 because you have to start from the left. So you have to do the division first

        • Cristopher Apoyon
          Cristopher Apoyon  2 days back

          8÷2(2+2)=1 in case you didn't know

          • badguy blah
            badguy blah  2 days back

            It's 1... Has no one heard of bodmas in US?

          • Ragib Ahmed Siddique
            Ragib Ahmed Siddique  3 days back

            the ans is only 1

            • Hyper Striker
              Hyper Striker  3 days back

              First is (2+2) = 4
              Second 8 ÷ 2 = 4
              Third is 4 x 4 = 16

              • Danny Anderson
                Danny Anderson  3 days back

                Without BEDMAS, its 16.With BEDMAS its 1

                • Alba G
                  Alba G  3 days back

                  So like I'm not American and I havent been taught with bedmas or whatever
                  Just brakets, then divisions and multiplicacions from left to right and then adding and substracting from left to right
                  If you have 1x2/2 yo do 1x2 first, if you have 1/2x2 you do 1/2 first
                  So 8/2(2+2) its obviously 16
                  I don't get why theres debate

                  • Jay Ryze
                    Jay Ryze  2 days back

                    either youre trolling, or you really dont know the answer:
                    8/2(2+2)
                    Since there is nothing between the 2 and the bracket you have to add a multiplication sign changing the problem to:
                    8/2*(2+2)
                    this turns out to be 8/8=1
                    The 2* has to be multiplied to both the 2's in the bracket.

                • issecret1
                  issecret1  3 days back

                  It’s not even a math problem. Seems more like a linguistics problem to me

                  • CitrycAcid
                    CitrycAcid  3 days back

                    https://www.mathsisfun.com/operation-order-pemdas.html

                    • Drewsta4
                      Drewsta4  4 days back

                      Never actually gave the answer though. It’s 16 , why not definitively state it?

                      • Jibran
                        Jibran  3 days back

                        It's 1. First you solve parenthesis, then the rest. Basic maths.

                    • valentin ursache
                      valentin ursache  4 days back

                      I'm curious how NASA calculated in the last 50 years how far stars are...or how many times they calculated wrong trajectory of the rockets or meteors ....

                      • Papapau
                        Papapau  5 days back

                        What is this BED? Eversince, i knew PEMDAS. Another divide.

                        • Rawdah Abdirizak
                          Rawdah Abdirizak  5 days back

                          8:2(2+2)= 8:2(4)=4*4=16

                          • Sardar Abdul Qayyum Khan

                            According to DMAS, the brackets are solved first, that would be 8/2 (4)=4(4)=16

                            • philip bucher
                              philip bucher  1 days back

                              @Lucas James everywhere in the world the result is 1
                              8/2(2+2)=1
                              forget that : that is kindergarten style

                            • Lucas James
                              Lucas James  3 days back

                              In Europe multiplication comes before division so it's 1 here

                          • Fausta Castaneda
                            Fausta Castaneda  6 days back

                            16. Only social media idiots would argue otherwise. That's why they're on social media.

                            • TheFangirl13
                              TheFangirl13  6 days back

                              8/2(2+2)=
                              8/(4+4)=
                              8/8= 1

                              • TheFangirl13
                                TheFangirl13  1 days back

                                @Alba G I was taught to expand the brackets first, 2(2+2) = 2x2 + 2x2

                              • Alba G
                                Alba G  3 days back

                                What, no
                                You first solve what's INSIDE the braket

                              • TheFangirl13
                                TheFangirl13  6 days back

                                Its not just BEDMAS but also expanding brackets

                            • cyber taste
                              cyber taste  6 days back

                              The answer is 16 :\

                              • Narah
                                Narah  7 days back

                                Pemdas? Guys??????

                                • Faisel Moh'd Muktar
                                  Faisel Moh'd Muktar  1 weeks back

                                  Only those who work on programming language would understand why that Math expression went that viral.

                                  • Jezze
                                    Jezze  3 days back

                                    No, I don't...

                                • Blessed
                                  Blessed  1 weeks back

                                  You more likely to get a job driving around then stationary.
                                  Blame uber not the drivers.

                                  • Lala Laiq
                                    Lala Laiq  1 weeks back

                                    When it says let's say, 2 (4), it means 2×4. When there is 1 number in a bracket, you dont solve it as if it's a bracket. You consider it being multiplied.

                                    So, 8÷2(2+2) is
                                    8÷2=4
                                    Then we solve the brackets, (2+2)= 4

                                    And then we multiply, 4(4)=16

                                    • Karajorma
                                      Karajorma  1 weeks back

                                      Suppose you have the equations x = a/bc and you also know c = d+e. If you believe the answer is 1, you can substitute for c and end up with x = a/b(d+e). If you believe the answer is 16 you can't. The act of substituting for c changes the result. You end up with two equations which should be equivalent but aren't. Maybe I'm missing something, but that doesn't sound right to me. You shouldn't be able to break algebra that easily!

                                  • InJo Kael
                                    InJo Kael  1 weeks back

                                    can we have uber for uber

                                    • Captain Phasma II
                                      Captain Phasma II  1 weeks back

                                      PEMDAS???
                                      Parenthesis,exponent,multipliacation,division,addition,substraction

                                      • I love you but
                                        I love you but  1 weeks back

                                        16

                                        • Kamal Aulakh
                                          Kamal Aulakh  1 weeks back

                                          8÷2*4 is not same as 8÷2(4). You always solve for Bracket/Parranethesis first. No Matter what system you are using(i.e BODMAS, PEMDAS).

                                          A Bracket/Parranethesis is not considered solved unless you eliminate it from the equation. It's is not eliminated by simply Replacing it with a × sigh. It is eliminated by performing the action. In this case 2(4) = 8.

                                          • Raven Bloodrose
                                            Raven Bloodrose  1 weeks back

                                            you do the brackets first, 2+2=4 then you do the 8 divided by 2 which is 4 and you multiply the 4 from the first half with the 4 from the half in the brackets giving you 16... that's how i was taught it

                                            • Reshy Tube
                                              Reshy Tube  1 weeks back

                                              Leave the answer below, No cheating please!

                                            • Farxiya Abdilaahi
                                              Farxiya Abdilaahi  2 weeks back

                                              Talk about Somalia and how it is now cualivalied the world cup

                                              • shawnwyr
                                                shawnwyr  2 weeks back

                                                Just use a calculator.

                                                • Mo n
                                                  Mo n  2 weeks back

                                                  My illegitimate child can find my address but not uber 🤣

                                                  • magnum357225
                                                    magnum357225  2 weeks back

                                                    the problem is not defining the corect symbol in front of the brackets 8÷2×(2+2) or 8÷2÷(2+2) and from that it would depend will it be 1 or 16

                                                    • Sean Cao
                                                      Sean Cao  1 weeks back

                                                      Unless the rule of Mathematics change in the last 8 years, 2(2+2) is always treated as 2×(2+2)

                                                  • Eirik Olsnes
                                                    Eirik Olsnes  2 weeks back

                                                    Depends what programming language you are using :)

                                                    • uildanach2010
                                                      uildanach2010  2 weeks back

                                                      The answer is 1. There is no other way to resolve that. You always resolve any fractions, parenthesis etc. Each side of the main equation before resolving it.

                                                      • Exotic Chaotic
                                                        Exotic Chaotic  2 weeks back

                                                        Isn’t the brackets just the simplification of the original equation? So the answer is 4? Im probably wrong but meh.

                                                        • Kristofer Quem?
                                                          Kristofer Quem?  1 weeks back

                                                          Nah.
                                                          Brackets show what you should do first, or give priority to a part of an equation.
                                                          For example: 8 ÷ 2(2 + 2)
                                                          In this example, you have to do 2 + 2 first, then the rest from the order of left to right.
                                                          That is:
                                                          8 ÷ 2 (2 + 2) =
                                                          8 ÷ 2 • 4 =
                                                          4 • 4 = 16.

                                                          Edit: Gramatical errors.

                                                      • Jack King
                                                        Jack King  2 weeks back

                                                        It's 1 how is it 16
                                                        8÷2(2+2)
                                                        =8÷2(4)
                                                        =8÷8
                                                        =1

                                                        So I understand how people can get 16 but the thing is in mathematics you can just put it in a calculator and get the answer it's step by step. When you put it in a calculator in whole it will divide 8 with 2 first before timing it with 4. The proper way is to times the 2 with 4 first because 2(n) is 2 times (n) since it should be split from divide beforehand.

                                                        • Kristina Koleva
                                                          Kristina Koleva  2 weeks back

                                                          ...does no one knows math order?! First you multiply,then you divide..It's 1

                                                          • Rahul Mondal
                                                            Rahul Mondal  2 weeks back

                                                            Nope.... Division and multipilication dont have orders same as addition n subtraction

                                                        • Crimson Hades
                                                          Crimson Hades  2 weeks back

                                                          The answer is 1.

                                                          • Gungun x
                                                            Gungun x  2 weeks back

                                                            its 16

                                                            • Noruane Daileg
                                                              Noruane Daileg  2 weeks back

                                                              I don't get why this is Even a Matter of debate. It's basically pemdas

                                                              • Hazel Mendes
                                                                Hazel Mendes  2 weeks back

                                                                Am I the only one who had to learn BEDMAS for computer, BODMAS for maths and BIDMAS for mental ability problems?

                                                                • Humera Ahsanullah
                                                                  Humera Ahsanullah  2 weeks back

                                                                  I think everywhere is BEDMAS (to solve in this order: Brackets, Exponents, Division, Multiplication, Addition, Subtraction) but US acronym is PEMDAS (to solve in this order: Paranthesis, Exponents, Multiplication, Division, Addition, Subtraction), is what the whole issue is. So which is correct? As it results in two different sets of answer: 16 and 1.

                                                                  • Gezai Enya
                                                                    Gezai Enya  2 weeks back

                                                                    Just saying using BODMAS...its 1

                                                                    • Life Scree
                                                                      Life Scree  2 weeks back

                                                                      order of operations...




                                                                      drops mic

                                                                      • wairimu254
                                                                        wairimu254  2 weeks back

                                                                        () of /x+- answer is 1

                                                                        • Kushko
                                                                          Kushko  2 weeks back

                                                                          You read math from left to right with priority given to adjacent multiplication/division. Of course it's 16. When you read books do you read from left to right only to randomly read certain words from right to left?