JOKER Reviews! (No Spoilers) Best Joker Yet?

  • Published: 04 September 2019
  • Joker Review! Early reactions to the Joker movie are in, with strong Rotten Tomatoes score and rave reviews from the Venice Film Festival. How does this Joaquin Phoenix Joker compare to the Heath Ledger Joker from The Dark Knight? How much does this Joker film connect to the DC world, and how could it connect to the upcoming Robert Pattinson Batman? Erik Voss breaks down what the critics are saying about this Joker (2019) film, what themes it explores, and why Joaquin Phoenix might be the second person to win an Oscar for playing the Clown Prince of Crime. In what ways is this Joker movie an homage to Martin Scorcese's Taxi Driver and The King of Comedy?

    Be sure to watch the upcoming episode of Rogue Theory in which the hosts of New Rockstars break down their Joker final scene theories!


    SPECIAL THANKS TO OUR PATREON SUPPORTERS (, including these beautiful people:
    Kelly Hopper
    Kenny Smith
    Wilhemina Ebbesen
    Matthew Salvas
    Pony Stark
    Matthew Ahrens
    Dory Zein

    Producer: Erik Voss
    Producer: Zach Huddleston
    Executive Creative Director: Filup Molina
    Post Production Supervisor: Devin Cleary

    Editors: Joshua Hurd, Devin Cleary, Aaron Carrión
    Music: "Sci Fi" from
  • Entertainment Entertainment

Comments • 764

  • skyflyer
    skyflyer  5 days back

    The movie is actually having a lot of mixed reactions and reviews as well now I think the newness of it is wearing off to people be able to kind of look at it clearly

    • Golon
      Golon  1 weeks back

      In my opinion Joaquin Phoenix as a Joker is a symbol for people who feel oppressed, same as Satan is for Satanists or one or two or hundred hackers are for Anonymous. What Joker is doing in the movie inspires a future "Jokers" we know from movies which happens to take an action in the future. Joker from the Dark Knight - probably a son of a Joker inspired by Joaquin Phoenix (the original Joker). That would explain why there's so many different Jokers, because they were all inspired by movement of one.

      • Pranas Vaicaitis
        Pranas Vaicaitis  1 weeks back

        DC has a lot of villains who could have origin stories which make us see them in likeable way. However, the question is if those transformarion stories wouldn't be kind of copy. In other words, transformarion caused by isolation, ignorance and people not apreciating that individual. For example I don't think Riddler's origin, transformarion story would be that much different than Joker's.

        • TechRyze
          TechRyze  2 weeks back

          Not watched many reviews where the narrator hasn't watched the film! 😃

          Review roundup, I guess...?

          • D.J.
            D.J.  2 weeks back

            Pause it perfectly at 6:57 . You’re welcome

          • Clifford Smallwood
            Clifford Smallwood  2 weeks back

            Whole time watching I’m thinking have on a jacket 🧥 🤨 lmaooo

            • terah101
              terah101  2 weeks back

              I hope it's as good as they say. They've also finished the script for Pattinson's Batman, apparently they're focusing on a detective based depiction with some realism. If that does as well as Joker, I think these two can kick start a shared sub-universe of their own within the DCEU.

              • Kaine ZarVel
                Kaine ZarVel  2 weeks back

                Idc it’s gonna be the best Joker film ever made

                • Buddah Kris
                  Buddah Kris  2 weeks back

                  Umm.. it's the ONLY one ever made. (Killing Joke doesn't really count, it's not all about him)

              • Boel B
                Boel B  2 weeks back

                Going to be amazing

                • Boel B
                  Boel B  2 weeks back

                  Movie of the year

                  • Erwin Garcia
                    Erwin Garcia  2 weeks back

                    Yes..Dark DC is the way to go...cant copy the formula of MCU

                    • BLINK ONCE
                      BLINK ONCE  2 weeks back

                      No way Pennywise the Clown is the best Joker yet

                      • Ladd Davies
                        Ladd Davies  2 weeks back

                        DC needs to embrace this darkness to succeed. Dark DC is always the best DC.

                        • k j
                          k j  2 weeks back

                          Dc black would be perfect for a zodiac killer type riddled movie

                          • Sergio Gonzalez
                            Sergio Gonzalez  2 weeks back

                            This should definitely be the standard 🤩

                            • Agg Or nah
                              Agg Or nah  2 weeks back

                              Heath ledger will be the best ever

                              • Jose Zambrano
                                Jose Zambrano  2 weeks back

                                So excited for this movie!!!

                                • הגר גדליוביץ'

                                  Rocketman got a 4 minutes standing ovation but Joaquin deserves an eight minutes standing ovation just for being himself so, yeah, I'm definitely not surprised. When the moment he opens his mouth wide like an animal came up in the trailer I said "WOW" out loud, in a theater full of strangers. It's going to be a once in a lifetime experience, especially for an editor and a writer and a film fanatic like myself.

                                  • Saubhgya Bammi
                                    Saubhgya Bammi  2 weeks back

                                    Joker don't look as terrifying as dark Knight joker

                                    • Vincent Simbol
                                      Vincent Simbol  2 weeks back

                                      The fellows in Venice really stood longer than this video?

                                      • Chris D
                                        Chris D  2 weeks back

                                        It's not hinting at more movies, it's just showing that this is Joker and ties it into an alternate universe of DC hero involvement. Off screen of course. It doesn't need to be related to more movies. If you look at DCs amaaaazing animated movies, very few are within the same reality as any other and they work perfectly.

                                        • I'm Slim Hounon the real Slim Hounon

                                          When you can't make your own review, you review everyone else's reviews 🤣

                                          • YT Lord Brawler
                                            YT Lord Brawler  2 weeks back

                                            THIS IS OBVIOUSLY GONNA WIN A OSCAR
                                            WHO ELSE THINK SO

                                            • Peter Liechty
                                              Peter Liechty  2 weeks back

                                              The Dark Knight will never be surpassed

                                              • sloth_ Al
                                                sloth_ Al  2 weeks back

                                                i still think heath ledger is going to be the best joker

                                                • Brian Burkhardt
                                                  Brian Burkhardt  2 weeks back

                                                  That Time review pissed me off more than it probably should have.

                                                  • Jason Morrison
                                                    Jason Morrison  2 weeks back

                                                    Can we get a dark and gritty TMNT movie please

                                                    • Maori Boy
                                                      Maori Boy  2 weeks back

                                                      Jack Nicholson set the standard.

                                                      • Mickey Morrow
                                                        Mickey Morrow  2 weeks back

                                                        The top comment is really “So you’re saying the joker will put a smile on my face”? Wow. And no. I don’t believe this version of Joker could even exist in a world where Heath’s Joker never happened.

                                                        • Will Kehler
                                                          Will Kehler  2 weeks back

                                                          Nope. Not the best joker yet lol. I don’t know why people need me to tell them that. What was so great about what we have been able to see from Joaquin’s joker? People literally lost their minds when the Dark Knight trailer was released

                                                          • Dan Olson
                                                            Dan Olson  2 weeks back

                                                            I had to exit this video due to my distaste for reading all these critic quotes. Absolutely ridiculous.

                                                            • ᴛɪᴋᴛᴋ ɢᴀᴄʜᴀɪɴᴄ.

                                                              What about a joker that is happy?

                                                              • Percy Almeida
                                                                Percy Almeida  2 weeks back

                                                                This year DC movies were awesome

                                                                • Caelan Wood
                                                                  Caelan Wood  2 weeks back

                                                                  14 minutes after released that's a record

                                                                  • A FLAME
                                                                    A FLAME  2 weeks back

                                                                    i like the ledger dezine

                                                                    • Midhun Toms
                                                                      Midhun Toms  2 weeks back

                                                                      I smell an Oscar award

                                                                      • Delbane Ren
                                                                        Delbane Ren  2 weeks back

                                                                        Not here for twifleck. That hot mess won't be watchable.

                                                                        • cody bot
                                                                          cody bot  2 weeks back

                                                                          If there was no batman there is no joker. Batman need joker read the comics

                                                                          • Maggie Doggie
                                                                            Maggie Doggie  2 weeks back

                                                                            It looks like a total POS

                                                                            • luke malave
                                                                              luke malave  2 weeks back

                                                                              DC should aim for a more mature audience in their movies and keep the tone dark like in joker

                                                                              • Ryan Ouellette
                                                                                Ryan Ouellette  2 weeks back

                                                                                Depends on what you mean by "standard," but if you mean a fresh take on old stories and characters, then yes. And I would be so SO happy if this connected to the upcoming Batman film.

                                                                                • Paul Bujak
                                                                                  Paul Bujak  2 weeks back

                                                                                  IS THAT A MEMBERS ONLY JACKET?!

                                                                                  • what and what
                                                                                    what and what  2 weeks back

                                                                                    heath ledger was the best now everyone is fighting for the second best spot

                                                                                    • Benjamin Porter
                                                                                      Benjamin Porter  2 weeks back

                                                                                      He hasn’t seen the movie yet...

                                                                                      • SteveBop
                                                                                        SteveBop  2 weeks back

                                                                                        Nice jacket!

                                                                                        • AltairLT
                                                                                          AltairLT  2 weeks back

                                                                                          Heath Ledger is the Best Joker. Period.

                                                                                          • D -TEK
                                                                                            D -TEK  2 weeks back

                                                                                            Sympathy not empathy

                                                                                            • Fialovej Biftek
                                                                                              Fialovej Biftek  2 weeks back

                                                                                              I know that this joker will be shit