Joe Rogan and Neil deGrasse Tyson Tackle Gravity

Share
HTML-code

Comments • 5 208

  • Roy Rosario
    Roy Rosario  28 minutes back

    R

    • Roy Rosario
      Roy Rosario  28 minutes back

      old time

      • sean rogan
        sean rogan  28 minutes back

        Science is supposed to be an unending search for knowledge. A real good question is why does he not want to keep working on the frontier?

        • Joe Dannar
          Joe Dannar  1 hours back

          I view Einstein's spacetime as a super-liquid and the Earth is the same volume as said liquid, because the Earth behaves in space exactly like a ball would in a vat of water if it were the same volume of the water it were in.

          • Allistair Neil
            Allistair Neil  1 hours back

            Newton never knew the word "spooky". Besides, he wrote in Latin. Einstein used the phrase concerning spooky action at a distance when referring to two electrons being quantum entangled with spin.

            • King David
              King David  2 hours back

              Joe Rogan "I don't think there is a purpose to life"

              Also Joe Rogan - working, dressing up, talking to people and living day to day as if what he just said was wrong and he had purpose

              Lol, this is why I cannot be an atheist, because no one that I know if actually lives there atheism out and is consistent with it

              If you say there is no purpose then don't be a hypocrite and live as if there is

              In other words, the way you live, treat people ect shows what you really believe, feel etc

              Joe says he thinks there might be no purpose yet with his life and actions he proved he actually thinks he has purpose

              The fact he brought this guy in to talk with him proved he thinks there is propose in it

              God gave us purpose, science is simply figuring out how God did it and the process behind how things work

              Take God out of the picture and you might as well take your brain out and throw logic out the window

              After all if it was true there is no purpose Joe and other atheist are the biggest hypocrites for acting as if they do and living as if they do

              In other words, your actions prove what you really believe

              Someone who doesn't believe there is a cliff will keep walking as if there is no cliff, the proof someone doesn't actually believe that though is when they go to walk over a cliff then stop as if there is one

              In other words, Joe and others are quick to call belief in God foolish and claim there may be no purpose

              Yet all of these same non believers and atheist live there like AS IF what they said is not true

              If Joe thought there was no purpose then he wouldn't be getting angry or come to work dressed in the morning or have conversations as if they matter

              Atheism is illogical

              If I told you I don't believe in gravity but I refused to jump off a cliff, it is sure proof that I deep inside believe gravity exist or is a force other wise I would jump

              And in the same manner, these people claim there is no God or purpose, yet they live as if they have purpose and come to work everyday

              Thanks for proving deep inside you know God exist and you know people have purpose

              After all would you invite this guy to your show if there is no purpose to it?

              Inviting this guy to talk proved he believes there is a purpose to it or he is actually a moron

              Take your pick 😂

              Life has a purpose given to us by God, the sure proof is the fact everyone around you keeps sucking wind everyday and gets up to go to work as if it matters

              Like I said, take God out if the picture and you make yourself a fool

              It doesn't matter how smart you are, remove God and you might as well say goodbye to logic and throw out your brain

              Oh and the fact you read this comment proved you thought there was a purpose of reading it

              Thanks for also proving yourself wrong lol by reading this

              God wanted me to say "In God's universe, logic and reason shows his handiwork and shows whom to trust and not"

              • George Costanza
                George Costanza  3 hours back

                Ask him why he never lost his virginity or why he feel so strongly about religion? No problem.

                Ask him why gravity works? Fuck you bald man 😡

                • Philip Zuchetti
                  Philip Zuchetti  4 hours back

                  Irritating....there is no "why".

                  • canbalcioglu
                    canbalcioglu  6 hours back

                    and this is why we see Neil only on tv/radio shows "talking" about but not actually contributing to science. he has lost his curiosity which should be the fuel of any scientist. Scientists like R. Feynman comes into my mind... Love the show, Cosmos though😅

                    • Grant Odermatt
                      Grant Odermatt  8 hours back

                      It is very important to know why and how gravity works not just to measure it , because that's the only way we are going to master it.
                      There are to many unanswered questions in general relativity and to many wrong astronomical predictions for us to say lets move on
                      we know all there is to know about gravity.

                      • Connor The Hill
                        Connor The Hill  10 hours back

                        Most people are saying Tyson looks like a douche in this and is mean to Rogan, but at the end of the day all he’s trying to do is help Rogan learn. He could be. Dick and be like “lol you idiot you don’t know anything compared to me” but he doesn’t. He tried to explain in his own weird way that if you keep asking why why why over and over again you eventually get to a point where an answer can’t yet be found. You can reach that point with asking about baldness and make it seem we don’t know anything about baldness or how it comes to be. Tyson seemed a little frustrated that people can keep asking “why” about gravity until they make it seem like we don’t know anything about it. Tyson misunderstood Rogan a bit and thought he was in a way having a go at what we know in science. Tyson ofc wants to defend that the best he can so he tried to teach Rogan as in depth as he could and so he may have interrupted Rogan a but but only to fully get his point across in the name of accurately explaining his ideas. In my opinion as long as you’re genuinly explaining something for the greater good (in this case, explaining a concept in science that will reach thousands of people which needs to be done properly) then it’s fine to interrupt someone a couple times as long as they know it’s not malicious or disrespectful. Because of who Tyson in and how people see him, he has to be really careful with what he says and how he says it especially when he’s explaining concepts in science so cut him some slack here guys. Joe was curious so he asked a why question, Tyson answered in a careful way. That’s all.

                        • thestrugglewithin
                          thestrugglewithin  13 hours back

                          Conclusion is the cessation of thought. This attitude of black science man just highlights The pompous self aggrandisement of the scientific community. They conclude, without fully understanding the concept, declare it consensus, and anyone asking alt questions is met with this dissonance and denial of defense. Fuckn lame.

                          • MTPatriot1787
                            MTPatriot1787  13 hours back

                            All he needed to say was: I don't have the answer, but I am good with the general exception and understanding. --- the statement of most.

                            He always gets argumentative about anything anyone asks for more understanding and elaboration.

                            • Daniel Bonne
                              Daniel Bonne  13 hours back

                              the why of purpose can never be answered because it is subjective and you will ask why ad infinitum the why of what something is cannot be answered by science it is answered by doing because by doing you enter objective reality where the subjective comes into conflict with the objective

                              • Daniel Bonne
                                Daniel Bonne  13 hours back

                                not only is Neil wrong that the hows will answer the why but i know what gravity is and why
                                gravity is
                                gravity is a "force" of consciousness, the universe is a conscious entity made of 4 dimensions the sum of which is the 5th dimension, gravity is what consciousness uses to see sum data, let me explain.....
                                stars are data points that sit on the space time continuum the gravity that pushes around all stars and matter maps out the sum of all that data its like if you touch 5 hings with 5 fingers the feeling your finger has on the individual object is the same as the gravity that hugs matter the sum of the gravity hug equates to the 5th dimension

                                • Alejandro
                                  Alejandro  14 hours back

                                  Defensive action taken when Science doesn't have an answer... But Why?

                                  • I Don't Want Any Trouble
                                    I Don't Want Any Trouble  15 hours back

                                    So Tyson's proof of gravity is that we can land on mars inside a crater? That is the proof? And we know that we have landed on mars how? Because we were told so by known liars?

                                    • Arizona Cardinals
                                      Arizona Cardinals  15 hours back

                                      Isn't there a place where cars roll uphill??

                                      • Kelly Jensen
                                        Kelly Jensen  16 hours back

                                        WTF Neil!!! You're argument is why we have people who ask nothing! People who never question religious authority, or upbringing. Always ask why! I personally don't care how well you can describe the magic trick, I want to know how the trick is done. It's great we have expert knowledge how gravity interacts with other objects, we don't know how it does what it does.

                                        • Rehab
                                          Rehab  16 hours back

                                          gravity is the earths electromagnetic field.

                                          • Death By Design Graphics
                                            Death By Design Graphics  16 hours back

                                            I think it is important to know why gravity works. It could lead to many other scientific advancements and perhaps even ways of controlling gravity. Needless to say that would be a very useful tool for space exploration technologies. Right now space travel is prohibitively expensive and finding ways to control this force could make it much much cheaper.

                                            • Run Platypus
                                              Run Platypus  18 hours back

                                              Just too many things that cannot be explained. We can't answer them ever because we're stuck in this 3 dimensional existence.

                                              • Bk Bk
                                                Bk Bk  19 hours back

                                                Jesus fuck Neil can be so dense. The ‘why’ and ‘how’ is not a duality, it’s a unity that better enables understanding of each concept. The why is used to explain how language evolved from an anthropological perspective and hermeneutical for example. Behind every great scientist is a philosopher which explains why Neil’s contempt for it severally hinders his thought.

                                                • Joseph Wright
                                                  Joseph Wright  19 hours back

                                                  If you could hack that fabric you can control gravity

                                                  • Adrian AMV Vasquez
                                                    Adrian AMV Vasquez  20 hours back

                                                    It's funny to see him piece together a theory. I don't understand anything he's explaining

                                                    • Sara Delana
                                                      Sara Delana  20 hours back

                                                      Any useful sentence from his mouth ? 😵🤦🏽‍♀️

                                                      • Lee weeks
                                                        Lee weeks  21 hours back

                                                        dickhead, yes we have seen Richard Feynman fun to imagine. I thought you where a scientist, not a parrot!

                                                        • V x.
                                                          V x.  21 hours back

                                                          Neil basically said “Fuck off about gravity Joe, you’re bald"

                                                          • Jason R S
                                                            Jason R S  23 hours back

                                                            Joe ,, you are a great host,,,

                                                            • Gudstuv
                                                              Gudstuv  24 hours back

                                                              Is there a direction in gravity?

                                                              • Mai-Tai
                                                                Mai-Tai  24 hours back

                                                                Neil is kind of being a pompous a hole

                                                                • Robert Alexander
                                                                  Robert Alexander  1 days back

                                                                  Joe wearing same shirt from last year's ndt interview

                                                                  • UNLIMITED SHIT
                                                                    UNLIMITED SHIT  1 days back

                                                                    Bonding stopped working.

                                                                    • Michael Little
                                                                      Michael Little  1 days back

                                                                      Uhm.. Neil did get defensive it's blatantly obvious. If he knows joe rogan's material enough he would understand Joe is being objective. So much passive hostility could have been avoided if Neil said "beyond the curvature of space time, "why" gravity exists isn't a frontier we have crossed yet" from the near beginning. I agree with Neil but if he would have just said that the convo could have been more productive.. To play devil's advocate to my own statement, it's blatantly clear we don't know the "why" to many things on 'that' level. It would be akin to discovering who or what created the particle that exploded into the universe as we know it, and the fully understanding the dynamics that went into that. It will either always be unanswerable and/or beyond the capacity of human understanding.

                                                                      • Strelok
                                                                        Strelok  1 days back

                                                                        Damn hes rude

                                                                        • Jon Tran
                                                                          Jon Tran  1 days back

                                                                          Gravity is the result of space/time interacting with matter/energy.

                                                                          • I Don't Want Any Trouble
                                                                            I Don't Want Any Trouble  22 minutes back

                                                                            @Jon Tran LOL! What does gravity have to do with anything you are talking about? Matter does not equate to gravity. Think about it.

                                                                          • Jon Tran
                                                                            Jon Tran  13 hours back

                                                                            Okaaay.....where does density come from if it’s not from matter? Lol

                                                                          • I Don't Want Any Trouble
                                                                            I Don't Want Any Trouble  14 hours back

                                                                            @Jon Tran So what? Matter and energy doesn't equate to gravity. Think about it.

                                                                          • Jon Tran
                                                                            Jon Tran  15 hours back

                                                                            Can’t have density without matter/energy......

                                                                          • I Don't Want Any Trouble
                                                                            I Don't Want Any Trouble  15 hours back

                                                                            Or it could just be density..

                                                                        • threemr01
                                                                          threemr01  1 days back

                                                                          While an infinite “chain of whys” can become very annoying (anybody who’s dealt with a small kid knows that), it is ridiculous a scientist such as NdGT tries to stop it by arguing “I already answered several of your whys.” Just imagine if Einstein had thought that way, and instead of coming up with his theories of special and general relativity, he had just gotten defensive of Newton’s LUG... we’d still be in the 1600s regarding astrophysics and cosmology.

                                                                          Joe really got Neil when he said he was very defensive. Good one, Joe! You are never intimidated by your guests, and always give though-out answers. Love your show.

                                                                          • Michael Sheridan
                                                                            Michael Sheridan  1 days back

                                                                            He literally beat that question around the bush for 10 minutes. I love NDT but damn he tried getting all philosophical and never answered shit

                                                                            • Craig Young
                                                                              Craig Young  1 days back

                                                                              Science man in 2019: Stop asking questions I already know enough and I'm good with that.


                                                                              I never thought I'd live to see science so hopelessly corrupted.

                                                                              • Billy poppins
                                                                                Billy poppins  1 days back

                                                                                Richard feynman answers why... 😁

                                                                                • Days Of Funder
                                                                                  Days Of Funder  1 days back

                                                                                  Man that was intense!!!

                                                                                  • humanzyx
                                                                                    humanzyx  1 days back

                                                                                    it really, really isn't a good look for Tyson to aggressively try and go overly philosophical

                                                                                    • William Cody
                                                                                      William Cody  1 days back

                                                                                      The best part was when he made Neil laugh is arse off

                                                                                      • Nunnha B
                                                                                        Nunnha B  1 days back

                                                                                        NDT - Listens to himself as he goes to sleep, then wakes up to pre-recorded message of himself, telling himself how awesome he is.

                                                                                        • Karl Childers
                                                                                          Karl Childers  1 days back

                                                                                          Mr. I'm such a freaking genius Tyson, please stop finishing every sentence with OK.

                                                                                          • Armando Eustache
                                                                                            Armando Eustache  1 days back

                                                                                            Neil Tyson a lieeee and wicked
                                                                                            You should be ashamed you puppet

                                                                                            • Freedom Works
                                                                                              Freedom Works  2 days back

                                                                                              That which we know - science
                                                                                              That which we don't know - philosophy
                                                                                              That which we wish wasn't - religion

                                                                                              • Freedom Works
                                                                                                Freedom Works  2 days back

                                                                                                Infinite regression